Jollys Jewellers

How To Tell Real Diamonds From Fake Ones

9th September 2015

Diamonds have long been popular on jewellery, and have long been expensive, luxury items. This has led to a long tradition of creating imitation diamonds to provide fashionable jewellery at a much more affordable price. When what seems to be diamond jewellery is inherited or obtained second hand with unknown provenance, a lot of people find themselves in the position of trying to work out whether the stones are real or fake. There are a few steps you can take to help find the answer.

8Ct White Gold Marquise Cut Diamond Solitaire and Accents

Examine Closely

The first step is simply to have a good look at the stone under magnification. Most diamonds are natural, and like most natural materials will display flaws when viewed through an eyeglass. Artificial diamonds will be virtually flawless. Remember, though, that this is only an indication. Some lab-grown diamonds that aren’t without value may appear flawless, and some other natural stones look like diamonds, flaws and all, but are not worth nearly as much.

Scratch It

Another test is to attempt to scratch it, as real diamonds are too hard to be scratched by everyday objects. In the past, the recommended tool was a sapphire-tipped gramophone needle, as sapphire will not scratch a real diamond but is hard enough to leave a mark on almost anything else. As these are no longer easy to come by, however, a good alternative is to give it a quick rub with sandpaper. A fake diamond or less valuable stone will be scuffed, but a real diamond will be untouched.

18Ct White Gold Diamond Solitaire & Accents Ring

Hold it up to the Light

The way diamonds sparkle is virtually unique. It’s a common misconception that diamonds sparkle with rainbow colours. They will project rainbow colours outside the stone onto other surfaces, but inside the stone should sparkle grey-white because light is so thoroughly scattered. If you see colours inside the stone, it’s probably not a diamond. If the stone isn’t in a setting, you can further test it by placing it on newspaper. With a diamond, the light should normally be so scattered as to prevent any black being reflected. If it is in a setting, then instead check whether you can see straight through the stone into the mounting – something that is normally not possible with a real diamond.

Professional Testing

Ultimately, unless you happen to have your own testing equipment the only way to be sure about whether a diamond is real or fake is to consult a professional jeweller or antique dealer. Big, glitzy, big-chain high street jewellers are probably not the best bet, as they mostly focus on selling their own brand new items and employ more salespeople than proper jewellers. Independent jewellers, antique dealers, and specialist gemologists are likely to be better-placed to tell you whether your diamond is real or fake, as well as probably more willing and quite likely more affordable. They can also help you work out how much the diamond is actually work. Even for diamonds of the same size, this can vary massively according to factors like cut, clarity and colour.

18ct White Gold Princess Diamond Solitaire with Accents Ring

Next Article

Jollys Create New Custom Piece for Client

Recently, the team at Jollys created a new custom piece for a customer, with fantastic results!

Visit Our Stores

Whether you desire an individual vintage piece or stunning modern lines, Jollys is the place for you. Jollys are established throughout the East Midlands, with jewellery shops in Nottingham, Ilkeston and our head office in Mansfield.

Visit Jollys Jewellers in Mansfield for Vintage, Antique & New Jewellery.


10-12 Market PlaceMansfieldNottinghamshireNG18 1HU
01623 652227
Visit Jollys Jewellers in Hucknall for Fine Jewellery and Professional Jewellery Services


25 High StreetHucknallNottinghamNG15 7HJ
0115 964 0200
Visit Jollys Jewellers in Ilkeston for Vintage, Antique and Fine Jewellery


71 Bath StreetIlkestonDerbyshireDE7 8AJ
0115 930 5562

Get Social With Us

Connect with Jollys Jewellers via social media to keep up-to-date with our latest news, blogs, competitions and promotions.

Jollys Jewellers on Facebook
Jollys Jewellers on Twitter
Jollys Jewellers on Instagram
Jollys Jewellers on Pinterest
Jollys Jewellers on Youtube